How to Choose Between 529 Plans: Direct Comparison of Your Options
There is no single "best" 529 plan — the right choice depends on your state, your child's age, and how you plan to use the money
A 529 plan that works well for one family may not work for another. The main decision is whether to use your state's plan or a plan from another state. Your state plan often has tax advantages if your state offers an income tax deduction for contributions. Out-of-state plans sometimes have lower fees or investment options that suit your situation better. The second decision is which investment strategy fits your timeline — aggressive growth if your child is young, or conservative if college is near.
This guide walks you through the real differences between plans so you can see which features matter to your situation. You will need to look at three things: whether your state offers a tax deduction, what the plan charges in fees, and what investment choices it offers.
Key Takeaways
- Most states offer a tax deduction on 529 contributions only if you use that state's plan, so check your state's rules before choosing an out-of-state plan.
- Direct-sold plans (you buy directly from the plan) usually charge lower fees than advisor-sold plans (you buy through a financial advisor).
- Age-based investment options automatically shift from stocks to bonds as your child gets closer to college, which removes the need to rebalance yourself.
- You can change your investment choice once per calendar year, and you can change to a different plan's investment options once per calendar year, but switching plans entirely has tax consequences.
State tax deduction: the biggest reason to use your own state's plan
If your state offers an income tax deduction for 529 contributions, using your state's plan usually saves you money. The deduction reduces your taxable income, which lowers your state income tax bill. The amount you can deduct varies by state — some states let you deduct unlimited contributions, while others cap the deduction at a specific dollar amount per year.
Not all states offer a deduction. Nine states have no state income tax, so there is no deduction to claim. Some states offer a deduction only if you use their plan; others let you deduct contributions to any state's 529 plan. Before you choose an out-of-state plan, check your state's tax rules. Your state's 529 plan website or your tax preparer can tell you whether a deduction is available and what the limit is.
The tax savings can be substantial over time. If you contribute $2,500 per year and your state tax rate is 5 percent, you save $125 per year in taxes. Over 18 years, that compounds. However, if your state's plan has much higher fees than an out-of-state alternative, the tax savings might not outweigh the cost difference.
Plan fees: direct-sold versus advisor-sold
529 plans come in two structures: direct-sold plans, which you buy directly from the plan provider, and advisor-sold plans, which you buy through a financial advisor. Direct-sold plans almost always charge lower fees because there is no advisor commission built in.
Fees are charged as a percentage of your account balance each year. A typical direct-sold plan charges between 0.10 percent and 0.30 percent annually. An advisor-sold plan often charges 0.50 percent to 1.00 percent or more per year. On a $50,000 account, the difference between 0.15 percent and 0.75 percent is $300 per year — money that could have grown in your account instead.
Some advisor-sold plans also charge an upfront sales load, which is a percentage of your initial contribution that goes to the advisor. This can be 5 percent or more of your first deposit. If you are comfortable choosing your own investments and do not need an advisor's guidance, a direct-sold plan saves you money over time.
Investment options: age-based versus individual funds
Every 529 plan offers a set of investment choices. The two main types are age-based portfolios and individual fund options.
Age-based portfolios automatically shift your money from stocks to bonds as your child gets older. You choose the expected college year when you open the account, and the plan rebalances itself each year without you doing anything. This is straightforward if you do not want to monitor your investments. The trade-off is that you have less control — the plan decides the exact mix of stocks and bonds at each age.
Individual fund options let you choose your own mix of stock funds, bond funds, and money market funds. You can be aggressive when your child is young and shift to conservative investments as college approaches. This requires you to rebalance yourself, usually once per year. If you want more control or have a specific investment philosophy, individual funds give you that flexibility.
Most plans offer both types. Some plans have more fund choices than others. If you have strong preferences about which companies manage your investments, check whether your preferred fund managers are available in the plan.
Comparing your state plan to out-of-state alternatives
To decide whether to use your state's plan or switch to another state's plan, gather three pieces of information: your state's tax deduction (if any), your state plan's annual fees, and the fees and investment options of the out-of-state plan you are considering.
If your state offers a substantial tax deduction and your state plan's fees are reasonable (under 0.40 percent per year), your state plan is usually the better choice. The tax savings typically outweigh higher fees.
If your state offers no tax deduction, or if the deduction is small, compare fees and investment options directly. A plan with lower fees and better investment choices may be worth using even if it is from another state. Some people use their state plan for the tax deduction and then switch to an out-of-state plan later if the state plan's performance lags significantly — though this has tax consequences, so check with a tax preparer first.
What happens when you change plans or investment choices
You can change your investment choice within the same 529 plan once per calendar year without tax consequences. You can also change to a different plan's investment options once per calendar year. These changes do not trigger capital gains taxes.
Switching from one plan to a completely different plan is more complicated. You can do a rollover, which moves money from one plan to another, but only once per 12-month period for each beneficiary. The money itself is not taxed, but if you have investment gains in the old plan, those gains move with the money and may affect your tax situation. Some plans also charge a fee to process a rollover.
If you are thinking about switching plans, talk to a tax preparer first. The tax consequences depend on your specific situation, and a professional can tell you whether a rollover makes sense for you.
Plans with special features: prepaid tuition and may provide growth
Most 529 plans are savings plans, which means you invest money and the growth depends on how the investments perform. Some states also offer prepaid tuition plans, which let you lock in today's tuition prices for future use.
Prepaid plans work differently from savings plans. You buy tuition credits at today's prices, and when your child attends college, those credits cover tuition at the locked-in rate. This protects you from tuition inflation. However, prepaid plans are usually limited to in-state public universities, and if your child attends a private school or out-of-state school, the value may be reduced. Prepaid plans also have different contribution limits and rules than savings plans.
A few states offer both a prepaid plan and a savings plan. If your state has both, you can compare them directly. Prepaid plans make sense if you are confident your child will attend an in-state public university and you want to lock in tuition costs. Savings plans offer more flexibility if you are unsure about your child's future school choice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a 529 plan from any state, or do I have to use my own state's plan?
You can use any state's 529 plan regardless of where you live. However, your state may only offer a tax deduction if you use your state's plan. Check your state's rules before choosing an out-of-state plan, because the tax deduction can be worth more than the fee difference.
What is the difference between a direct-sold and advisor-sold plan?
Direct-sold plans charge lower annual fees because you buy directly from the plan provider with no advisor commission. Advisor-sold plans charge higher fees and sometimes an upfront sales load because a financial advisor is involved. If you are comfortable choosing investments yourself, direct-sold plans cost less over time.
Should I choose an age-based portfolio or pick my own investments?
Age-based portfolios are simpler because they rebalance automatically each year. Individual fund options give you more control but require you to rebalance yourself. Choose age-based if you prefer a hands-off approach; choose individual funds if you want to manage your investment mix.
What happens to my 529 if my child does not go to college?
You can change the beneficiary to another family member, such as a sibling or cousin. If you withdraw the money for non-education purposes, the earnings are taxed as income and you pay a 10 percent penalty on the earnings only (not the contributions). Some states also impose state income tax on the earnings.
Can I move money from one 529 plan to another?
Yes, through a rollover. You can move money from one plan to another once per 12-month period per beneficiary without triggering taxes on the contributions. Investment gains move with the money and may have tax consequences, so check with a tax preparer before rolling over.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.