Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How Car Recalls Affect What You Can Sell Your Car For

A recall lowers resale value, but the amount depends on whether the repair was done and how serious the defect was

A car recall is an announcement from the manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) that a vehicle has a defect affecting safety or emissions. When you sell a car with an open recall — one the previous owner never had repaired — buyers will discover it during a pre-purchase inspection or title check, and most will either walk away or demand a price cut. Even after a recall is repaired, the fact that the recall happened stays on the vehicle's history report and can still reduce what buyers will pay, though the damage is smaller.

The size of the price hit depends on three things: how serious the defect is, whether the repair was completed, and what kind of car it is. A recall for a seat belt that does not lock properly will cost you less in resale value than a recall for a transmission that can suddenly shift into neutral. A luxury car with a completed recall might lose 5 to 10 percent of its value; a used economy car might lose 10 to 15 percent. The only way to know what a specific car will bring is to get it inspected by a mechanic and then list it and see what offers come in.

Key Takeaways

  • An open recall (one that has not been repaired) will show up on the vehicle history report that most buyers pull, and most buyers will either refuse to buy or demand a significant discount.
  • Even after a recall is repaired, the recall remains on the car's permanent history, and buyers may still pay less because they know the car had a defect.
  • The price reduction varies widely depending on the severity of the defect — a safety issue costs more in resale value than a minor emissions problem.
  • You can check what recalls explore to your car by entering its VIN on the NHTSA website at safercar.gov, and you can have the repair done for free at any authorized dealer.

How buyers find out about recalls

Most used car buyers run a vehicle history report through Carfax or AutoCheck before making an offer. These reports pull data from NHTSA, state DMV records, and insurance claims, and they list every recall ever issued for that vehicle, whether it was repaired or not. A buyer who sees an open recall will almost always ask about it, and if you cannot show proof that the repair was done, they will either walk away or use the recall as leverage to negotiate a lower price.

Some buyers also search the NHTSA database directly using the car's VIN. If you are selling privately, a serious buyer will do this. If you are trading the car in to a dealer, the dealer will know about the recall and will factor it into their offer before they even talk to you.

The difference between a repaired recall and an open one

If the recall has been repaired, the history report will show that too — it will list the recall and note that the repair was completed, including the date and mileage. This is much better for resale value than an open recall, but it is not the same as if the recall never happened. Buyers still see that the car had a defect, and some will assume there is a higher risk of other problems or that the repair might not hold up.

An open recall is far worse. Buyers assume the defect is still present, and they will either refuse to buy or demand a steep discount — often 10 to 20 percent or more, depending on how serious the defect is. Some buyers will make an offer conditional on you having the repair done before they take possession, which means you will end up paying for the repair anyway.

What kinds of recalls hurt resale value the most

Safety recalls cost you more in resale value than other types. A recall for a faulty airbag, a brake system defect, or a steering problem will reduce the price more than a recall for a seat belt that does not lock or a door latch that sticks. Buyers are willing to accept minor inconveniences, but they are afraid of defects that could cause a crash or prevent them from stopping the car.

Transmission and engine recalls also hit hard because they affect the core of the car and can be expensive to fix. A recall for a transmission that can shift into neutral without warning might reduce resale value by 15 to 25 percent. A recall for a fuel tank that can leak might reduce it by 10 to 15 percent. A recall for a dashboard light that does not work might reduce it by 2 to 5 percent.

The age of the recall matters too. A recall from five years ago that was repaired promptly will hurt less than a recall from last year that is still open. Buyers assume that if a defect was not fixed quickly, the owner did not care about the car's condition.

How to check if your car has an open recall

Go to safercar.gov, the official NHTSA website, and enter your vehicle identification number (VIN). The site will show you every recall issued for your car, the date it was issued, what the defect is, and whether the repair has been completed. You can also enter your phone number and email, and NHTSA will send you notifications if a new recall is issued for your car in the future.

If you find an open recall, you can have the repair done for free at any authorized dealer for that brand. The manufacturer pays for the parts and labor. Call the dealer, give them your VIN, and ask them to schedule the recall repair. It usually takes a few hours to a day, depending on what the recall is.

What to do if you are selling a car with a recall history

If the recall has been repaired, get the service records from the dealer that did the work. These records prove to the buyer that the repair was completed, and they will reduce the price hit. If you do not have the records, ask the dealer for copies — they keep them in their system.

If the recall is still open, have it repaired before you list the car. The cost is zero, and the repair will make the car much easier to sell. If you list the car with an open recall, be honest about it in the listing and in conversations with buyers. Do not hide it — they will find out anyway, and hiding it will make them trust you less and demand a bigger discount.

If you are trading the car in to a dealer, the dealer will know about the recall and will subtract it from their offer. You cannot avoid this, but you can ask the dealer to have the repair done before they resell the car, which might make their offer slightly higher because they will not have to do the work themselves.

How much value you actually lose

The price reduction varies by the car, the defect, and the market. A 2019 Honda Civic with a completed recall for a faulty seat belt might lose 3 to 8 percent of its value. The same car with an open recall might lose 15 to 25 percent. A 2015 Toyota Camry with a completed recall for a transmission issue might lose 8 to 12 percent. A luxury car like a BMW or Mercedes might lose less in percentage terms because the buyer pool is smaller and more willing to accept a car with history.

The best way to know what your car will bring is to get a pre-purchase inspection from a trusted mechanic, list the car, and see what offers come in. You can also check recent sales of the same model and year with similar mileage on Kelley Blue Book or NADA Guides to get a baseline, then adjust down based on the recall.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will a recall show up on a Carfax report?

Yes. Carfax pulls recall data from NHTSA, so every recall issued for a vehicle will appear on the report, whether it was repaired or not. If the repair was completed, the report will show the date and mileage of the repair.

Can I sell a car with an open recall?

Yes, but most buyers will either refuse to buy or demand a significant discount. You are not required to repair it before selling, but you are required to disclose it in most states. Having the repair done first will make the car much easier to sell.

Do I have to pay for a recall repair?

No. The manufacturer pays for all recall repairs, including parts and labor. You can have the work done at any authorized dealer for that brand at no cost to you.

How long does a recall repair usually take?

Most recall repairs take a few hours to a full day. Some are quick — replacing a part or reprogramming software — while others take longer. Call the dealer and ask how long the specific recall will take before you schedule it.

Does a recall that was repaired years ago still affect resale value?

Yes, but much less than an open recall. A buyer will see on the history report that the recall happened and was repaired, and some will pay slightly less because they know the car had a defect. The longer ago the repair was done, the smaller the impact on price.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.