Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Counts as a Good 401(k) Return

A good 401(k) return depends on what your money is invested in, not on a single target number

There is no universal "good" return for a 401(k). The return you should expect depends entirely on how your money is invested — whether it sits in stable, low-growth accounts or in stock-heavy portfolios that swing up and down. A 2% return might be excellent if you are in a bond fund designed to protect your money. The same 2% return would be disappointing if you are in a stock fund that historically averages 10% over long periods.

The real question is not "Is my return good?" but "Is my return reasonable for the type of investment I chose?" This guide explains what returns look like across different investment types, how to find what you are actually invested in, and how to think about your returns without chasing unrealistic numbers.

Key Takeaways

  • Stock funds historically return around 10% per year on average over decades, but individual years can be negative or much higher.
  • Bond funds typically return 3% to 5% per year and fluctuate less than stock funds.
  • Target-date funds (which shift from stocks to bonds as you near retirement) return somewhere between stock and bond returns depending on your age.
  • One year's return tells you almost nothing — compare your fund's performance to its benchmark over three, five, or ten years instead.
  • Your 401(k) statement shows what fund you own; the fund's prospectus or fact sheet shows what historical returns that specific fund has delivered.

How stock funds and bond funds return differently

A stock fund invests your money in company shares. Historically, the stock market has returned around 10% per year on average over long periods (30+ years). But that average hides huge variation. In some years the market rises 20% or 30%. In others it falls 20% or 30%. If you are 25 years old and will not touch your 401(k) for 40 years, a down year is actually useful — your contributions buy shares at lower prices. If you are 62 and retiring next year, a down year is painful.

A bond fund invests in loans (usually to governments or corporations). Bonds return less than stocks over time — typically 3% to 5% per year historically — but they bounce around far less. A bond fund might return 4% one year and 3.5% the next. A stock fund might return 15% one year and -8% the next. This is why people shift from stocks to bonds as they get closer to retirement.

Your 401(k) statement will show you which funds you own. Look for words like "Stock Fund," "Equity Fund," "Bond Fund," or "Fixed Income Fund." If you see "Target-Date 2050," that is a fund that automatically mixes stocks and bonds based on when you plan to retire — it acts like a stock fund now and gradually becomes more bond-like over time.

What "good" means for each fund type

Once you know what you own, you can check whether it is performing reasonably. Your 401(k) provider's website usually shows your fund's one-year, three-year, five-year, and ten-year returns. Ignore the one-year number — it is too short to be meaningful. Look at three years or longer.

For a stock fund, a reasonable return over three to ten years is somewhere in the 7% to 12% range. If your stock fund returned 5% per year over five years while the overall stock market returned 10%, your fund is underperforming. If it returned 11%, it is doing well. The comparison that matters is called the benchmark — usually the S&P 500 for large-company stock funds, or the total stock market index for broader funds.

For a bond fund, a reasonable return over three to ten years is 2% to 5% per year. Bond funds are judged against bond benchmarks like the Bloomberg Aggregate Bond Index. If your bond fund returned 2% while bonds overall returned 4%, your fund is lagging.

For a target-date fund, compare it to other target-date funds with the same retirement year. A target-date 2050 fund should behave similarly to other 2050 funds because they all hold roughly the same mix of stocks and bonds.

How to find your fund's benchmark and historical returns

Your 401(k) provider sends you a statement at least quarterly. On that statement, find the name of each fund you own. Then go to your provider's website (Fidelity, Vanguard, Schwab, or whoever runs your plan) and search for that fund by name.

The fund's page will show a fact sheet or prospectus. This document lists the fund's returns for the past one, three, five, and ten years, and it names the benchmark — the index the fund is trying to match or beat. Write down both the fund's return and the benchmark's return for the same time period. If the fund is within 1% of the benchmark, it is performing as expected. If it is 2% or more below the benchmark year after year, the fund is charging too much in fees or is poorly managed.

Some 401(k) plans offer index funds, which straightforward track a benchmark and charge very low fees. These almost always match their benchmark closely because that is their only job. Other plans offer actively managed funds, where a manager picks individual stocks or bonds trying to beat the benchmark. These charge higher fees and sometimes beat the benchmark, but often do not.

Why one year of returns means almost nothing

Your 401(k) statement might show that your stock fund returned -5% last year. That feels bad. But a single year is too short to judge. Stock funds have negative years regularly — roughly one in four years is down. If your fund is down 5% while the benchmark is down 6%, your fund actually did well.

The longer the time period, the more meaningful the comparison. A three-year return shows whether your fund kept pace through a mix of up and down markets. A five-year or ten-year return is even better. If your stock fund has returned 8% per year over the past ten years and the benchmark returned 9%, your fund is performing reasonably — it is only 1% behind.

Market timing (trying to sell before a drop and buy before a rise) almost never works. Most people who try it end up selling low and buying high. The better strategy is to check your fund's long-term performance once a year and rebalance if needed — moving money between stock and bond funds to keep your target mix.

When to worry about your fund's performance

You should consider switching funds if your fund consistently underperforms its benchmark by 2% or more per year over five years or longer. This usually means the fund is charging high fees or the manager is making poor choices. Before switching, check the fees. Many 401(k) plans list the expense ratio — the percentage of your money the fund charges each year. A stock index fund might charge 0.05% per year. An actively managed stock fund might charge 0.75% or higher. The difference adds up over decades.

You should also check whether your plan offers better options. Some 401(k) plans have limited fund choices and high fees. If your plan offers both an index fund and an actively managed fund tracking the same benchmark, the index fund is usually the better choice because it costs less.

Do not switch funds because of one bad year or because a friend's fund did better. Markets move in cycles. A fund that underperforms one year often outperforms the next. Switching chases performance and usually costs you money in trading fees and taxes.

How inflation affects what "good" really means

A 4% return sounds decent until you remember that inflation (the rising cost of goods) erodes that return. If inflation is 3% per year and your fund returns 4%, your real return — what your money can actually buy — is only about 1%. This is why stock funds matter for long-term retirement savings. Over decades, stocks have returned enough to beat inflation by a wide margin. Bonds usually beat inflation, but only slightly.

When you read that the stock market has returned 10% per year historically, that is before inflation. After inflation, the real return is closer to 7%. This is still much better than bonds, which return about 2% to 3% after inflation. This is why younger people should hold mostly stocks — they have time to ride out the ups and downs and benefit from that higher real return.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is 6% a good return for my 401(k)?

It depends on what you own. If you are in a stock fund, 6% per year over five years is below the historical average of around 10%, so you might be underperforming. If you are in a bond fund, 6% is excellent. Check your fund's fact sheet to see what benchmark it tracks, then compare your fund's return to that benchmark's return over the same period.

Should I move my money to a different fund if it had a bad year?

No. One year tells you almost nothing. Stock funds have down years regularly. Compare your fund's return to its benchmark over three, five, or ten years. If it is consistently 2% or more behind over a long period, then consider switching. Otherwise, stay put.

What if my 401(k) returned less than inflation?

If you are in a bond fund or stable value fund, this can happen in low-inflation years. Over long periods, bonds should beat inflation, but not by much. If you are in a stock fund and it is losing to inflation year after year, your fund is performing poorly and you should investigate the fees and benchmark.

How do I know if my fund's fees are too high?

Look for the expense ratio on your fund's fact sheet — it is listed as a percentage. Stock index funds typically charge 0.03% to 0.20% per year. Actively managed stock funds charge 0.50% to 1.50%. Bond index funds charge 0.03% to 0.15%. If your fund charges significantly more than these ranges, ask your plan administrator whether lower-cost options are available.

Is my 401(k) doing well if it matches the benchmark exactly?

Yes. Matching the benchmark means your fund is doing exactly what it is supposed to do. Most actively managed funds fail to beat their benchmark after fees, so matching it is actually a win. Index funds are designed to match their benchmark, so exact matching is expected and good.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.