HomeCredit-Score-FaqDoes-Closing-A-Credit-Card-Hurt-Credit-Score

Does Closing A Credit Card Hurt Credit Score?

Understanding the Impact of Closing a Credit Card

Many consumers ponder whether closing a credit card will harm their credit score. The relationship between credit cards and credit scores is intricate, involving numerous factors. This response aims to demystify the interplay between closing a credit card and its effect on your credit score. By the end, you should have a thorough understanding of how this action can impact your financial health and know the steps to mitigate any negative effects.

The Components of Credit Scores

Before delving into the effect of closing a credit card, it's essential to comprehend how credit scores are calculated. In the U.S., the most commonly used credit scoring model is the FICO score, which comprises the following components:

  1. Payment History (35%): This is the most significant factor, reflecting your reliability in paying bills on time.
  2. Credit Utilization (30%): This ratio compares your credit card balances to your credit limit and emphasizes the importance of keeping your balances low relative to your limits.
  3. Length of Credit History (15%): A longer credit history is generally favorable, as it provides lenders with more data on your creditworthiness.
  4. Credit Mix (10%): Having a variety of credit types (e.g., credit cards, auto loans, mortgages) can positively influence your score.
  5. New Credit (10%): Frequent applications for new credit accounts could negatively impact your score, as they might indicate financial difficulties or over-reliance on credit.

How Closing a Credit Card Affects Your Credit Score

Closing a credit card can impact several components of your credit score. By understanding these implications, you can make informed decisions about which accounts to close, if any.

1. Impact on Credit Utilization

The credit utilization ratio is one of the most immediate areas impacted by closing a credit card, as it directly reduces your available credit limit.

  • Example: Assume you have two credit cards, each with a $5,000 limit, resulting in a total available credit of $10,000. If you carry a balance of $2,000 across both cards, your credit utilization ratio is 20% ($2,000/$10,000). Closing one card reduces your available credit to $5,000, while your balance remains $2,000, thus increasing your credit utilization to 40%. This shift can lead to a lower credit score.

2. Length of Credit History

When you close a credit card, the account continues to appear on your credit report, generally for up to ten years. However, eventually, it will drop off, potentially shortening your credit history.

  • Example: If the closed card was one of your oldest accounts, the impact could be more significant since your average account age would decrease when it is removed from your report.

3. Loss of Credit Mix

If the closed card is your only revolving credit account, shutting it down could diminish your credit mix. Lenders and scoring models often favorably view a portfolio with diverse credit types, and a sudden lack of variety may impact your score negatively.

Evaluating When to Close a Credit Card

Closing a credit card isn't inherently good or bad; the decision largely depends on your financial circumstances and objectives. Consider the following scenarios:

High Fees and Unnecessary Cards

  • Annual Fees: If a card carries high annual fees and you don't utilize its rewards or benefits, it may be worth considering closing it, particularly if doing so won't significantly harm your credit utilization ratio or length of credit history.
  • Duplicate Cards: Redundant or lesser-used cards with no fees could be low-priority candidates for closure.

Better Offers and Simplification

  • Improved Offers: Sometimes, closing a lesser card works if you've secured better rates or rewards elsewhere.
  • Account Management: If managing multiple cards is overwhelming, consolidating may streamline your finances.

Steps to Mitigate Any Negative Effect

If you decide to close a credit card, take steps to mitigate potential negative impacts on your credit score:

  1. Pay Down Balances: Before closing, reduce outstanding balances on other credit cards to maintain a healthy utilization ratio.

  2. Check Impacts on Credit Limit: Ensure that closing an account doesn't increase your credit utilization to concerning levels.

  3. Retain Older Accounts: If possible, keep your oldest credit accounts open, as they positively affect the length of your credit history.

  4. Avoid New Applications: Limit new credit applications before and after closing an account to prevent unnecessary hard inquiries on your credit report.

  5. Keep Track of Reported Credit: Confirm that your closed account is reported accurately to the credit bureaus.

FAQs About Closing Credit Cards

Will closing a credit card account hurt my credit immediately?

It's possible, especially if your credit utilization increases significantly. However, credit history and credit mix are components that will affect your credit standing over time.

Can I ask my issuer to lower or waive my annual fee instead of closing the card?

Yes, some card issuers may agree to waive or reduce the fee, especially for long-term customers in good standing.

How long will a closed credit card remain on my credit report?

Typically, closed accounts remain on your credit report for about ten years, continuing to factor into your credit history’s length positively during this time.

Should I close dormant credit card accounts?

Dormant accounts can be useful for maintaining your credit limit, helping keep your utilization ratio low. However, if managing them is burdensome or they come with high fees, closure might be the best path.

Additional Resources for Further Learning

By carefully weighing the pros and cons, and taking strategic steps to protect your credit score, you can make informed decisions about closing credit cards. Explore more financial topics on our website to empower your financial journey.