Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to Understand ESG and Socially Responsible Investing

What ESG and socially responsible investing actually mean

ESG stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance — three categories that measure how a company operates beyond just making profit. Environmental means the company's impact on climate, water, and waste. Social means how it treats workers, customers, and communities. Governance means how the board runs the company and whether executives face real accountability. A socially responsible investment is money you put into companies or funds that score well in some or all of these areas.

The confusion starts because there is no single official definition. One fund company's "responsible" investment might exclude oil companies but include banks that finance fossil fuels. Another might focus only on worker treatment. A third might screen for all three but use different standards. When you look at an ESG fund, you are not looking at a regulated category the way you would with a bond fund or a stock index fund — you are looking at a fund manager's own choices about what matters.

This matters because it changes what you actually own. If you buy a fund labeled "ESG" without reading what the fund company screened for, you might end up holding companies you thought you were avoiding. The fund prospectus — the legal document the fund company must give you — will list the specific criteria they use. That document is where the real information lives.

Key Takeaways

  • ESG funds use different screening standards, so two funds with the same label may hold completely different companies.
  • The fund prospectus tells you exactly which companies the fund excludes and why, and this is the only reliable place to check.
  • ESG funds typically charge the same fees as regular stock funds, though some charge slightly more.
  • Choosing an ESG fund does not mean your returns will be lower, but past performance of one fund does not predict another's future results.
  • You can build a socially responsible portfolio by mixing individual stocks, mutual funds, and ETFs rather than relying on one fund's definition.

How ESG funds screen companies and what gets excluded

Most ESG funds use one of two approaches: negative screening or positive screening. Negative screening means the fund excludes entire industries or companies that fail certain tests. A fund might exclude all fossil fuel companies, all tobacco makers, all private prisons, or all companies with poor labor records. Some funds exclude multiple categories at once.

Negative screening sounds straightforward but creates real gaps. If a fund excludes "fossil fuels," does that mean oil drilling companies only, or also refineries, pipelines, and companies that generate electricity from coal? Does it exclude banks that lend to oil companies? Does it exclude car manufacturers that make gas-powered vehicles? Different funds draw these lines differently, and the prospectus should spell out exactly where.

Positive screening works the opposite way: the fund actively seeks out companies that score highest on ESG metrics. Instead of excluding bad actors, it overweights good ones. A fund might rank all companies in its universe by environmental impact and hold only the top 50 percent. This approach lets you own a broader range of industries but concentrates your money in companies the fund manager believes are leading on ESG issues.

Some funds use a hybrid approach: they exclude certain industries entirely (like tobacco) but then use positive screening within the remaining universe. The prospectus will describe the exact method. If it does not, contact the fund company directly and ask for their screening criteria in writing before you invest.

The difference between ESG funds and values-based investing

ESG investing and values-based investing are not the same thing, though people often use the terms interchangeably. ESG is a measurement framework — it is about data and metrics. A company either has a board diversity policy or it does not. It either reports carbon emissions or it does not. Values-based investing is about your personal beliefs. You might believe fossil fuels are wrong, or that certain industries conflict with your religion, or that worker treatment is the most important factor.

An ESG fund uses ESG data to make decisions, but the fund manager decides which ESG metrics matter most. A values-based fund is built around a specific set of beliefs — often religious or political — and screens companies based on whether they align with those beliefs. A Catholic values fund, for example, might exclude contraception manufacturers and abortion providers in ways that have nothing to do with ESG metrics.

If you have specific values you want your investments to reflect, look for funds that explicitly state those values in their name and prospectus. Do not assume an ESG fund shares your priorities. Read what the fund actually excludes and includes. If the fund's screening does not match what matters to you, keep looking.

How to read an ESG fund prospectus and find the real screening criteria

The prospectus is a legal document, and it is dense, but the screening criteria are usually in the first few pages under "Investment Strategy" or "Principal Investment Strategies." Look for a section that lists what the fund excludes or includes. It should name specific industries, specific metrics, or specific thresholds.

A weak prospectus will say something like "the fund invests in companies with strong ESG practices." A strong one will say "the fund excludes all companies that derive more than 5 percent of revenue from coal mining or coal-fired power generation, and excludes all companies with a board that is less than 30 percent women." The second one tells you what you actually own.

Look for these specific details: What industries or companies are excluded entirely? For companies the fund does hold, what ESG metrics does it measure? Does it use a third-party ESG rating service like MSCI or Sustainalytics, or does the fund company do its own research? How often does the fund review and update its holdings based on ESG performance? If a company in the fund gets worse on ESG metrics, does the fund sell it?

You can find prospectuses on the fund company's website, usually under "Documents" or "Fund Information." If you cannot find it, call the fund company's customer service line and ask them to email it to you. They are required to provide it.

ESG fund fees and whether they cost more than regular funds

ESG funds charge fees the same way regular mutual funds and ETFs do. The expense ratio is the annual percentage you pay to own the fund — it covers the fund manager's salary, research, and operating costs. A typical stock mutual fund charges between 0.05 percent and 1 percent per year. An ESG fund typically charges in the same range.

Some ESG funds charge slightly more because the fund manager does custom ESG research instead of using a third-party rating service. Others charge the same or even less because they use a straightforward negative screen (like "exclude tobacco") that does not require much ongoing research. There is no rule that ESG funds cost more — it depends on the specific fund.

When comparing funds, look at the expense ratio first, then look at what you get for that fee. A fund charging 0.50 percent that does deep ESG research might be worth more than a fund charging 0.10 percent that uses a basic screen. But a fund charging 0.75 percent that straightforward excludes one industry might not be worth the extra cost compared to a 0.25 percent fund with similar holdings.

You can compare expense ratios on the fund company's website, on financial websites like Morningstar or Yahoo Finance, or in the prospectus itself. The expense ratio is always listed in the first few pages.

Building your own socially responsible portfolio instead of relying on one fund

You do not have to buy an ESG fund to invest responsibly. You can build your own portfolio by mixing individual stocks, regular index funds, and ESG-focused funds based on what matters to you. This approach gives you more control over what you actually own.

Start by deciding which industries or practices you want to avoid. If you want to exclude fossil fuels, you might buy a broad stock index fund (which holds thousands of companies) and then sell the energy stocks, or you might buy an energy-free index fund instead. If you care about worker treatment, you might research individual companies and buy stock in ones with strong labor practices, or you might buy a fund that screens for that specifically.

You can also use a mix: a core holding of a low-cost broad index fund, plus smaller positions in ESG-focused funds or individual stocks that align with your values. This approach keeps your costs down while letting you direct some of your money toward companies you believe in. It also protects you if one fund's screening criteria change — you are not dependent on a single fund manager's definition of responsible investing.

If you want help researching individual companies, websites like Just Capital, B Lab, and the Sustainable Apparel Coalition publish rankings of companies by industry. These are free resources that show how companies score on specific ESG metrics. You can use these rankings to identify companies you want to own, then buy their stock directly or find funds that hold them.

What the research actually shows about ESG fund performance

The question most people ask is: do ESG funds make less money than regular funds? The honest answer is that past performance varies widely, and past performance does not predict future results. Some ESG funds have outperformed the market. Some have underperformed. Some have matched it. The same is true for regular funds.

What matters more is the specific fund's strategy and the time period you are looking at. A fund that excludes energy stocks will perform differently than the overall market when energy stocks are rising, and better when energy stocks are falling. A fund that screens for profitability and strong governance might perform well in a downturn because it holds stable companies. A fund that focuses on growth companies in renewable energy might be more volatile.

When you look at a fund's historical returns, remember that you are looking at one fund's past, not a prediction of its future. The fund manager might change. Market conditions will change. The companies in the fund will change. A fund that beat the market for five years might underperform for the next five. This is true for ESG funds and regular funds alike.

The best approach is to choose a fund based on its screening criteria and fees, not on past returns. If the fund's ESG standards match your values and the fees are reasonable, the fund is worth owning regardless of whether it beat the market last year. If you are investing for 20 or 30 years, short-term performance differences matter far less than the costs you pay and whether you actually stick with the investment.

Common mistakes people make when choosing ESG investments

The biggest mistake is assuming that a fund labeled "ESG" or "sustainable" or "responsible" matches your personal values without reading what it actually excludes. Two funds with nearly identical names might have completely different holdings. One might exclude fossil fuels but hold tobacco companies. Another might exclude both but hold private prisons. Read the prospectus before you buy.

The second mistake is chasing past performance. A fund that beat the market last year might underperform next year. Choosing a fund because it had the highest returns in the past five years is a common way to buy high and sell low. Choose based on the fund's strategy and fees, not its track record.

The third mistake is paying too much in fees for a straightforward screen. If a fund straightforward excludes one industry and charges 0.75 percent per year, you might be better off buying a low-cost broad index fund and selling the stocks you do not want to own. The math often works out cheaper, especially if you have a large portfolio.

The fourth mistake is assuming that ESG screening guarantees ethical behavior. A company can score well on ESG metrics and still have serious problems. ESG measures what companies report and what is visible in data — it does not measure everything. A company might have a diverse board and still treat workers poorly in ways that do not show up in ESG ratings. Use ESG as one tool, not the only tool.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do ESG funds make less money than regular stock funds?

Not necessarily. Some ESG funds have outperformed regular funds, some have underperformed, and some have matched them. Past performance varies widely and does not predict future results. The fund's specific strategy, fees, and the companies it holds matter more than whether it carries an ESG label.

What is the difference between ESG and socially responsible investing?

ESG is a measurement framework using data about environment, social, and governance practices. Socially responsible investing is a broader approach based on personal values. An ESG fund uses ESG metrics to make decisions. A socially responsible fund might use ESG data, religious beliefs, political values, or other criteria. Always read what a fund actually screens for.

Can I invest in ESG funds through my 401(k) or IRA?

Many employers now offer ESG fund options in their 401(k) plans, and most brokers offer ESG funds and ETFs for IRAs and regular taxable accounts. Check your plan's investment menu or call your plan administrator to see what ESG options are available. If your plan does not offer any, you can ask your employer to add them.

How do I know if an ESG fund is actually screening for what it claims?

Read the prospectus and look for specific exclusions and metrics, not vague language. Contact the fund company directly and ask them to explain their screening process in detail. Ask how often they review holdings and whether they sell companies that fail their ESG criteria. A fund that cannot answer these questions clearly might not be screening as rigorously as it claims.

What if I want to invest responsibly but do not want to pay higher fees?

Buy a low-cost broad index fund and manually exclude the stocks or sectors you do not want to own. Or build a portfolio mixing a low-cost index fund with a smaller position in an ESG fund focused on your specific values. Many ESG funds charge the same fees as regular funds, so compare specific funds rather than assuming ESG costs more.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.