We Olive is a subscription service that delivers olive oil to your home on a regular schedule
We Olive sends you bottles of olive oil every month or every other month, depending on the plan you choose. You pick a subscription length — usually three, six, or twelve months — and the company ships the same oil (or a rotating selection) to your address on that schedule. You pay upfront or per shipment, and you can pause or cancel anytime, though some plans charge a fee if you stop early.
The service is built around the idea that olive oil is fresher and cheaper when you buy it in bulk from a producer rather than from a grocery store shelf. We Olive sources from farms, mostly in California and sometimes internationally, and sells direct to subscribers. The oils arrive in dark glass bottles to protect them from light damage.
Key Takeaways
- We Olive sends you a bottle or set of bottles on a monthly or bi-monthly schedule, and you choose the subscription length when you sign up.
- You can select a single oil to receive repeatedly, or opt into their rotating selection to try different varieties each month.
- Subscription plans vary in price and commitment length, and most allow you to pause or cancel, though early cancellation may carry a fee depending on your plan.
- The oils ship in dark glass to preserve freshness, and most arrive within one to two weeks of your order date.
How to choose a We Olive subscription plan
We Olive offers several subscription tiers. The most common structure is a choice between a single-bottle plan (usually around 500 milliliters) or a multi-bottle bundle. You then select how often you want shipments — monthly is standard, but some plans offer every other month. The longer your commitment (three months versus twelve months), the lower the per-bottle cost typically is.
When you sign up, you also choose whether to receive the same oil each time or to have We Olive rotate their selection. The rotating option means you might get a robust California extra virgin one month and a lighter, buttery oil the next. If you have a favorite or cook with a specific type regularly, the fixed option lets you stick with it.
Pricing varies by oil type and bottle size. Premium or single-estate oils cost more than their standard blends. Before committing to a longer plan, check whether We Olive offers a trial or shorter initial subscription so you can test the service and the oil quality first.
What happens when your oil arrives
Shipments typically arrive within one to two weeks of when your subscription cycles. We Olive sends tracking information via email, so you can see when the package is on its way. The bottles come in a padded box designed to prevent breakage during shipping.
When the box arrives, inspect the bottles for any damage before opening. Olive oil should be stored in a cool, dark place — a kitchen cabinet away from the stove is ideal, not above the counter where light and heat can degrade it. Unopened bottles in proper storage last about two years; once opened, use the oil within a few months for the best flavor.
Pausing, changing, or canceling your subscription
Most We Olive plans allow you to pause your subscription for one or two billing cycles without losing your spot or paying a fee. You typically manage this through your account on their website — log in, find your subscription settings, and select pause. When you are ready to resume, you can restart from the same page.
If you want to change your oil selection or switch to a different subscription frequency, you can usually do that through your account as well. Some changes take effect on your next shipment; others may require you to cancel and restart a new subscription, which could affect your pricing tier if you were locked into a longer commitment.
Canceling outright is straightforward if you are outside any commitment period. If you signed up for a twelve-month plan and cancel after three months, We Olive may charge an early termination fee — check your plan terms when you sign up to see what that would be. Cancellation requests usually take effect after your next scheduled shipment processes.
Comparing We Olive to grocery store olive oil
Grocery store olive oil sits on shelves under fluorescent lights for weeks or months before you buy it, which degrades the flavor and some of the nutritional compounds. We Olive ships directly from the producer to you, so the oil is fresher when it arrives. The dark glass bottles also protect it during storage and shipping.
Price-wise, We Olive's per-bottle cost is often lower than buying premium olive oil at a grocery store, especially if you commit to a longer subscription. However, you are paying upfront and receiving shipments on a schedule, so it works best if you use olive oil regularly and have space to store extra bottles. If you buy olive oil only occasionally or prefer to pick your brand at the store, a subscription may not be the right fit.
What to know about olive oil quality and storage
Olive oil quality is measured partly by how it is made — cold-pressed or extra virgin oils are less processed and retain more flavor than refined oils. We Olive typically sources extra virgin and premium oils, which means they are higher quality than many grocery store options, but the term "extra virgin" is not regulated the same way in every country, so quality can still vary.
Once your oil arrives, store it in a cabinet or pantry, not in a clear bottle on the counter. Heat, light, and air all degrade olive oil over time. If you receive more oil than you can use in a few months, consider whether you have room to store it properly. Olive oil does not go bad quickly, but it does lose its fresh, complex flavor as it ages.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change my subscription after I sign up?
Yes. You can usually pause, change your oil selection, or adjust your shipment frequency through your account on the We Olive website. Some changes take effect when ready; others explore to your next shipment. If you want to cancel, you can do that too, though early cancellation may carry a fee if you are in a commitment period.
What if a bottle arrives broken?
Contact We Olive customer service with a photo of the damage. Most companies replace broken bottles or issue a refund for that shipment. Keep the damaged bottle and packaging until you hear back, as they may ask you to return it or provide more details about the damage.
How long does olive oil last once I open it?
An opened bottle of olive oil stays fresh for two to three months if stored in a cool, dark cabinet. After that, it does not spoil, but the flavor flattens and some of the health benefits fade. Write the date you opened it on the bottle so you know when to use it up.
Do I have to pay for shipping?
Shipping is usually included in the subscription price, so there is no separate shipping charge per order. However, check the plan details when you sign up to confirm. Some plans may offer free shipping only for certain commitment lengths or order sizes.
Can I gift a We Olive subscription to someone?
Many subscription services, including We Olive, offer gift subscriptions that you can purchase and send to another person. The recipient typically receives a set number of shipments, and then the subscription ends unless they choose to continue it. Check the We Olive website for gift options and pricing.